Reedies Help Free Innocent Man

On October 27, 2026, Carl Case left the Penitentiary of New Mexico as a free man for the first time in 44 years. Beside him walked the pair of Reedies who helped to prove his “actual innocence”: his attorney Clay Wilwol ’17 and University of New Mexico Professor of Law April Land ’83. 

Case entered prison after a conviction in 1982, where he was sentenced to life in prison plus an additional 14 years for the rape and murder of a teenage girl, Nancy Mitchell. A combination of factors led to his exoneration: in 2007, the New Mexico Supreme Court began allowing incarcerated individuals to make arguments about their innocence; new evidence was brought to the court surrounding forensic entomology; and years of work by attorneys and students in the University of New Mexico law program. 

Clay Wilwol ’17 is one of the attorneys who put in the legwork to ensure that Case was one of the first New Mexico inmates released under the 2007 provision. After leaving Reed, Wilwol attended law school at University of New Mexico, where he refined his skills. Land ’83, who went on from her education at Reed to teach at the University of New Mexico, said, 

“I had the privilege of watching Clay Wilwol (and lead counsel, Marc Lowry—who is not a Reedie) conduct the actual innocence trial last fall. His questioning of the expert bug witnesses demonstrated the intellectual curiosity and vibrancy cultivated by our education and the culture at Reed.  Thanks to his brilliant trial skills, and those of another of my University of New Mexico School of Law graduates, a New Mexico District Court found Carl Case to be actually innocent of the crime for which he has, tragically, served 44 years in prison.” 

Land and Wilwol had the great privilege of meeting Case at the gates of the penitentiary and walking with him to freedom. In this set of extraordinary circumstances, these Reedies were able to meet the moment and make change in the world. Case said that his legal team kept his hope alive, despite years of appeals being denied:

“They believed in me. They were the only ones that did, so I believed in them.”

You can read more about this story via the reporting by KRQE News or the Santa Fe New Mexican.

Case’s legal team, including Wilwol, have put together a GoFundMe to help support his re-entry into society: Fundraiser by Rothstein Donatelli LLP : Ignite A Life After 44 Years of Illegitimate Incarceration. They have asked us to share this alongside the story.